Pension settlement would leave central question unanswered - News, Weather and Classifieds for Southern New England

Pension settlement would leave central question unanswered

Posted: Updated:
CRANSTON, R.I. -

Rhode Island's proposed pension settlement would end a lawsuit, but some had hoped it would also settle the question of whether the state can change pension terms.

But lawyers in the case say even a trial wouldn't have answered that question, which affects 60,000 working and retired teachers and government workers.

When it became clear both sides were seeking a settlement that would avoid a trial, many were upset the courts would not deliver a final ruling on the question of whether the legislature has the right to reduce benefits.

But three of the lawyers in the case, speaking on this week's "10 News Conference," agreed that letting the case go through the court system would not necessarily deliver a final answer.

"The idea that we would have gotten a definitive ruling that would have lasted for all time -- I've been in this business for a while and that doesn't usually happen," said Lynette Labinger, an attorney for various unions.

What made both sides come together to support the adjusted pension reform is the avoidance of the lawsuit, putting to rest any question over what a trial might produce. But as Director of Administration Richard Licht explained, there's no promise a trial would even settle that question.

"There are people criticizing this, saying why don't you get that answer? We could go through this whole trial for years and years and years. We'll get a result, but we might not get an answer to that question because it can be decided on other grounds," said Licht, who's negotiating for the state.

Attorney Mark Dingley of the General Treasurer's Office said a ruling could be made based on conditions that are not universal.

"The ultimate legal question the court has to answer is, was this change reasonable and necessary for an important public purpose? That's not an answer that you can say 'yes' or 'no' to and it decides all future cases. It's based on the facts that occurred in 2011, circumstances of the state, circumstances of the legislature, and so forth," Dingley said.

Now begins a process of getting approval, first from the unions that were in the suit, and then from all retirees. That's before the General Assembly needs to pass a new law to create the proposed changes.

  • Local PoliticsMore>>

  • Obama arrives in RI, heads to Newport fundraiser

    Obama arrives in RI, heads to Newport fundraiser

    Friday, August 29 2014 7:19 PM EDT2014-08-29 23:19:51 GMT
    President Barack Obama meets with Gov. Lincoln Chafee and U.S. Sen. Jack Reed at T.F. Green Airport in Warwick.President Barack Obama meets with Gov. Lincoln Chafee and U.S. Sen. Jack Reed at T.F. Green Airport in Warwick.
    President Barack Obama is on a fundraising blitz and Newport is one of his stops.
    President Barack Obama is on a fundraising blitz and Newport is one of his stops.
  • Lt. Governor candidates say priority is putting RI back to work

    Lt. Governor candidates say priority is putting RI back to work

    Friday, August 29 2014 4:01 PM EDT2014-08-29 20:01:33 GMT
    NBC 10's Bill Rappleye (left) speaks with Secretary of State Ralph Mollis, Cumberland Mayor Dan McKee and state Rep. Frank Ferri during a taping of "10 News Conference".NBC 10's Bill Rappleye (left) speaks with Secretary of State Ralph Mollis, Cumberland Mayor Dan McKee and state Rep. Frank Ferri during a taping of "10 News Conference".
    All of the candidates, Secretary of State Ralph Mollis, Cumberland Mayor Dan Mckee, and state Rep. Frank Ferri, say closing the skills gap and putting people back to work would be their first priorities.
    All of the candidates, Secretary of State Ralph Mollis, Cumberland Mayor Dan Mckee, and state Rep. Frank Ferri, say closing the skills gap and putting people back to work would be their first priorities.
  • Year ends with $68M surplus; most already used

    Year ends with $68M surplus; most already used

    The state of Rhode Island ended the last fiscal year with a $68 million surplus, though $59 has already been used to close a hole in the General Assembly's current year spending plan.
    The state of Rhode Island ended the last fiscal year with a $68 million surplus, though $59 has already been used to close a hole in the General Assembly's current year spending plan.
Powered by WorldNow

23 Kenney Drive
Cranston, R.I., 02920

Telephone: 401.455.9100
Fax: 401.455.9140
Email: news@wjar.com

Can't find something?

NBC 10 Outerwear Provided by:

NBC 10 Media Relations
Provided by:

Powered by WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Media General Communications Holdings, LLC. A Media General Company.